1-1

---

14th

February, 1980

Thank you so much for having sent a copy of the speech which you made in Cambridge last week. It was very good of you to have done this, and I enjoyed reading it.

Ian Gow

The Rt. Hon. Sir Ian Gilmour, Bt. M.P.

0.77704

14cAta

7/2-/ tokAX, SIIL 10,14 Giv.....1nr

•

7TU

ErLflAYH

vuy rnm;PrTTfl TE INVITET TOFiI"F TALvcNCONSFRYPTISfl, UNTIL F:7 F YEARS ITYASA SHFJECT YHIcr CTNANRED LITTLE INITREQT PTN "ITHIN THERANKS oFTHE cr7sFpuTIVE LIIL THATFASrffPrn."OT v Po ccNS7RwTIVES APITE NFL UN"°"TTINTELLECTUrY, ALOLT "HATEXPCTLY THEYSHOULP TFLIPE (ANfRUflEPT YHICHI HUE YILLBE CONDUCTER ITH°YT THE PERSONAL INToLERANCE YHICH FUEL' cn r,"Hrsu t DISCUSSION T!''' THELAPOUP PARTY), FORETHANTHIS, THEREISALSOCROYINT, INTFREsT OUTSIRE THECoNSEPVATIVF POLEINTrE ITE7 7iCr ITr\TFwED Eirn cwPE OURvITYflF THE'J';RLR, PFoRLF SAYP.RoNT r, ITISTIFFICULT TO CONTENT TP/7 rr17 . s,

777.-7,7",

L_

I

TrEflE .APE SP'EPJ 71r:SrYS FOPTHIScROYTP

oF T"TDMC-7FIRST, THFRE HIS r7TIIPTFPLY Prr---nn .1.1!

AN IrTE1117TIIRL "

IlpI(1

7.

! pr' n'c

nE

rF Pflu:CIFF ANDrorv' ITY iic:irsT -FE

l\ rCE JJ;L_.

FOvIET IDFOLo7N, T LflDE 71,1\T TT — in-,

PE DL

ILI

I HAVEJLSTS,YID OF 1:11-1.0

Tliflp;PT

DE,,7r,

/

flETPT-W1

r,nr-HT

TV

'TTnULLY ISr L."SERVITIS TUT BRITISH -Fc.,7 nmTrnwnr,)-IN AT Ill, THISISOF rod!RsE 107n

7.1

VF-Apc

2:

TTrtTin^,I 7V

rilTIV‘I

USSI/TS TS, THE THEU7ISAN_THECOrnLIPIS AID ET "flrrilflp P'rT THEN/7I-SOVI SIr,ED THEC-EPTUS OF DIPLO7TAIT) OFFICE A FOREIrT YU,CEPT!M, ANDOrINUSEVENT:"AILTHE'I" THATGREAT rr,,,;(-Enuf,TTc,r, HAvrPECTE'""""I' .L Foiv,cF , "FLL imp 1-17n FEr'n77T74^ r IS 7 T TYP-SELvL TO,r-L,f-,P THEA_HITYOFCIT'SERvi.TIVFS j

!nT

/Tcr/

Tmrr n

TT 11

, fl

1.:LL

2

-

VE TOFLUISH THECMSERVATIPAUY Lo

L!riLLPLRTIFc.

UVF

•

p.Ft'

-t

t'AlAroy Ht,TcH

TO fl r,-'1-17-11rC (---\7,c,E7,:vATT\/E nTunn

i•

CUrt12,TrIC re-,fliTTrIMC"LII\C 1,..dis2

TJ

inLirILTriE('

i 11E-1-)

11,y

„JitLj_

Tp J._:

r"ATI'Ll tLJ111

CCNSFPVITIVE POLITIM T (7"PEP=C7IPPER nOnc A vrpy ASA VERYSAILSUBJECT u!, E. ITCA,t,'FE FEGARDED - A :pyST.'.ALL TH=SENSE THATTHERE A - 7 1EYHOTHIN!: THAT r'E.P,'ATIVE POLITICAL TPflUnHT 7,0Ec NoTFYIcT ISINPE=D TUTY-lA CONTLADICTICI ILTERrS. TI

!!

CERTAINLY MANYCONSERVATIVES T,AKE A NOT VERYELEVATED vIp (IF POLITICAL THOUGHT AN1THEORY, THEIROHTLOOK CANBE ILLUSTRATFD EYTHEYOUNGER PITT'S COMfl_U ONBURKE'S 1:TITIrGs ONTHEFPFMPH REvOLLTION, HESAID, YOUYIILvEUEUBP, THAT HEcr\Y I"THE YHCHTOflU lEE NOTHING TOArREE "ITH Qn CO'!S=RVATIVES THINK THATPOLITICS PLACTICPL LATTER ANDSHOULT '1OT PESIILIEr, TYEDY op7V INTELLECT TPFY NOTSOnUCH 1

tip

DISTRPTTHErRYAS REGARD IT AS IRPELEYT, THEY"IGHTAGREE YITHNOPUPDOPGLAS'S pr7ARV unmcrtic

"Ar dAn FELIEVEI . CflHSIFEPPLEDElL nr sp fq71VPT nn r,M 1T HT(' FIlLY n 7

NATPULANDCHEEPFH1

H

THAT c

Fil=riTr \

Tr! j

V I

TRPFOF SONELAPPUR r,P #, Rt.mFYL-r1criETM7.1V

I.FEYCOSERVATIVES - TPIINGH LIFERAL DPs TEND TOBELIEVE THENMSFNSE IATHOUT HAVING THE CHEERFUL 7NNER, CERTAINIY CONSERVATIVES ARFSUSPICIPPS OF ItTnrcp CERTAIM SORTS OFPOLITICAL THEORISING, INPISVEYEnu 'THEPOLITICS OF FPERFESTIFY, ANTHONY WINTrN, RIGHTLY I THIU, FIPDFTHE THE EOHUTIOHrFCONSERVATISfl INYHATHF qT7TFTInfl rFTHERADICAL INTELLECTPAL FPFPFECTION OETHEHPFAII INrIvPUAL', I-MT THATENPHATICALLY nn:Q "T RULE 0'7 fdLRol TI-Trq -1-FriPTQpr;

• pnrIr) TOTHEORY EUPLELAS LOTroc ,; AS SUCH, P.SAINST YPF:HESPOKE THEORY, PESAID,'IIT_AN I

AI WV('

A IVA1/ r

L

FDDr1"nlIC

7r,IlinTnmc HHPF!PNT)E1-1 -

•

nr) ILPERFUT THEOPY

LDOLEnFTHF YAYS DISCOVERING THATITIQFLLCJ-: THFflPY ISFY mccnIdrTniEc DpnTiC:'''PITf fl'RIHGYIT" h"n DIsLTvE "H'THiTncinDTH rAlin 'HPsTiTT THF°RY' THATISTOSAYLARGE OVERARCHING ABSTRACT SYSTrS OF LEASOR IDFOLOGIES, WHICH PURPORT TO ETFODY UNIVFRSAL IITUTAFLE TRUTHS THATAREINFALLIFIE GUIDES TOPOLITICAL BEHAVIOUR. nr !*

,fl

IC\

I

;

:

THEYFELIEVE INSTEPTHATPOLITICAL THEORY SHOULD FE EIIRIRICALLY 701TflEn, SHCVLDPF Fi"HL1 (;P\OUNDFD INRRACTIFF, SOFARAS COSERVATIVES APF CrIrTEUED THEREISA!'' II:PORTANT RISTFCTION RFTYFEfl THFO7Y AU IDEOLOGY, TO'AICH I PPE To pr---111p [ATFP

• THENECESSARY THHF,"HILE FnLY ACCEPTING PO!ITICALTHoUGHT, OF CONSERVATIVE LIFITATIONS I TEIK THES",EJECTI "As AcTEDTP TALvA7nHT Cri77".nr, , ANDIS liFnw I nr- r nr,7 VIES EXIST

TnTRYTODEAL"ITH JLST FFST TrFETHEREFORE v ?Pr npn-Tc OF IT, FTReTi T"oASPECTS HELPSTO EXPLAIN YHICH CONSEDVATISE, PPITIS-1 HEREISDIFFEPENTHON "HYcoNsEDNJIsr COFTRIES, [_flDALSoYHY INOTHER CONSEOVPTISL ANDSECO"LY, PEPEIS YHATIT IS. COUSEPVATISr TOTHE ATTITUDE CONSERVATIVE THEPREFENT--PAY i'SPECTIS FOREEASILY STATE: THIS SECOND:

AT ME DOPTs AFTERHpvIu, up A LOOK CnNSIDERED

CFCONSERVATISN, PF nONSERvr‘TIs" THEPOnTS FIRST, FIPTY ITDTHEOOPSEDVITIVE ELROPE N JOINED Fr:ITAI TriT Tnpr Pr CriQTT-M".77, L;t "P"IT" ""T -fl TP JnI" LI,

17

LI

4THflEP DnflTTP-C.

IN

n r=11;-. EJ

r ITTq_LY THEY

YERE vFRYSUSPICIOUS OFUSPECAPSE OFPU.D r7F, DI F_TrflE. Ev ITIETTIY 'CoHcERvterIwF' SflETHING '1; L\

vL

urDF F.DCY'UNIT TT e 3

:H._

.1.

FrPOPF,

TT

'I7

YP,C'

C':

TILLQOYETHI"'FnIPTv PORn /,

1,1,s

, _

!H HOrEv=P, FRENCH, BRITISH CONSERVATISF ALLHAVEINCOrH0r,,, THATISTHEIR ORIGIN IN,OPINREACTION FROF, THEFRENCH REVOLUTION, NOTSURPRISINGLY, THE REACTION W_NGTHEFRENCH TOTHEFRENCH REVO1UTION PASP GOODDEAL FOREEXTREFF THANWASTHEREACTION rONGT E ERITISH. BURKE, M Y UNDERFSTIflATER THEREEICIFNCIES OFTHF PASJUSTIFIED IrSAYINn RE(=rE - I TT' TflTPAPF THATHEPITIED THEPICAK FUTFoPHTTHE1--)YINr, LIPP, - BUTYHILE PEYASVSDUING1rHISCo7!Fr1TIoN OFTHEREVOLUTION, HEWASHOTROANTOEYTprrrs F!HISRUCTION TOIT. T'

Y,7)

• r-TL -7) Ii

rcç

pF\In11:Ti(v1:=D7rifli(T!'CFP11,ATTC7'

rpmGoTFIXED UP

THr

IT

T7F7

n L ` P W ITT17111 1

.7

r!--11PFH CHRISTFN1T UDFRA H:ITFD

— CnETW/1-IVE1', FELIEVED

7-7

LO THr IHE

DAQT0

PE

71.)flj

uiU,1

FEYCH

on11-T-mr1

T rr

75 -

E-

!'NITY TUriT

7,.,

T[

i

HITYMST PF CYPIFH-, non7 PP.rPDHATION rp Fnn :; TLIcrFCCA/ CUPRFISES OFDE7)C7,ACY rRLIBERTY, PL[INLY UNITY INTHATSPSFISFITHER THERE ORIT IS NOT:THFRE CAN?F NOPARTIAL urITY.PHD EQUALLY PLAINLY, DFFOCRACY AND/OR IIBFPTY APE L1AELE TOLEAD - ORRATHER, '1FCESSARIIY LEADFRACTUJT:T OFTHAT1,JITY. THEPEFCR.E LIFFRTY A7)DFFPCRACY AREINCOrFATITLF YITHTHE r-El T1-)A1 It! C17272,SE FRE'NC--;. OCNSERVATIVE ULLCra 117L.7777;—;L.,7

L_7,,71

^

7!!F-7,

cprHrr

rrTh:CFP\IrT

csr

ml--)n Uf HD ,

7

DP n

FARCIrcFR TrROHcs:,1! TH",TPFURKEI.AND ITS

VISIO:! OFHARITNY ANDUNITY nDE ITUTOPIAN HICHTrTHFEYES N-TpTTIcv f-c,,,ccnyqpirc IC -1-'1E VERYOPPOSITE OFOONS,TvATISF,

• rflkIcrflYnTTc.1" PrIT TrTn - LH c.P707,1 „ I nrvEr) TOPPI)IF HP ITI Crin Pr.r'f\r'7 I ; L.LL nTrli 1/T71!ihLni-,7 ,c;:n\ty

,TT

' ;

UrcTL7r

1

WL

.-

i

H

YPY

7

R/TIONL TH" ITs CTATT: Ur(' pHliv L. . ‘.1 LL ,

T:Tr.rn

L

r'7p7r--no Lj

,11

TL!r-

rUfT,IL- iTTEu

STATEYASFORE;,Lti Pr'LIT" T"' I"THE ,;T,14 nr I"IvIF"'L SAFEUAYTHU THEYPOLFIS floREr_L THINITc 1 5 /LL KNol,HrEDETEL l IDEAENDEFUP, L):;!:

PRITISH CONSEVATISF PLSOnATESFROF' THE FRENCHFFvOLPTION,(AnD TN FY VIFY THEFRY PIDTY DATESFROFTHESIVEPERIOD, THOUrTH -FL:I Is TflU7 CERTAnY POOPFOPUGHLENTHOYT TUE: L NOTE .-IrTfc" Wfl IIn°2-1-1 nrITOPIPTH). PUTBRITISH Cfll',2 pr!IcrLiWTTCr.' THE=XCESSFS OF FRE"CH ANFCFRFAU cnrA woTETv(7_7 Tr7DE REASONS . FTPCTI -ijV TT IQ \q-:DV YnnFvnIzTIN OR FOREIUcorpr,(7, i! QUM C DIFFICEIT TO FF CONSERVATIVE TNTrrFRITISH SirT AFTFRA FEVOLHTION,criT'm v Trc , , :

1Hc.J rEoUT nlInflflE

-

Tr n(T,FcT HD TDFcTr.:cT[pi rcurn L.L

1HTnn,IV 7MT-r-rt!'' MrCfl CETTIE7 1 i!I I ITTTrr!

I

nn! ITTrr,1

Trri)

r:

11

T\117'12

r

,

IRITISP CHSFFV:JI,7, ITS rEVFN SPHUTTO DEsTurSONETHIC THATHADBEENIOST Tc RETHR" TO A DEVIOUSALLEGEDIY GOLDEN AGF, OR TO flOVE INTOA NEYIDYLLICCONDITION OF THINGS. AQ

A RESULT, NEITHER THEID-AS OFTHEFRENCH

TeTHE PEVOLVTION NORTHEIDEAS OFTHEREACTION EDE.iru Lv REVOLUTION PADAS TUGH iTACi[LLD F AS -,E Pfl H.

1-1('r14117n7

TPFP7

. L

ppiTrr

1-11_

12TPLITfl !IrTTEvIQT TnEAC ACAINST THEVAVESur uiD JLp ""TIE HE TOOK I HIGH 1knurPCOUNTRIE S. \,Ti171` CF THESTATE - 'THEc-FTF- IQ r 117)DTtirDCLITn INALLPEPFICTION .„, HOLDTHEORGPNIC VIE1OFTHESTATE CPSOCIETY,THESTATE, HE f\r,1-,E)Cr.*TC.f.' crT,Fwv.QTyr BIT PFLTFVFn 'HAS INuu!Lp,u J

• T!

r7H

--;

T

E

7r' T

,__

'

HEDIDrflT PELIEYE THATSPIRITUAL or r=crIE-c-TTIr'r'i

UNITYCOU1D02 SHOULD DE r-7.,rnur.71 7,'7 1T 1

1:T7'117,'11r,C71-17;_ THP117P1,117-11 ;

P^,-,7-,T-

-

i

"T

;

AEsTRACT 'POLITICAL sPECUI ATIsr IQnr nnnpc,7 TDHE Pr.kfTr, ut±._!1\,...-,:J.:n!'. flE IT ISHCAUSFOF ITSORIGINS, BECAUSE CGPSETATISF TIn rOTINENGLA'T FALLM VIPGr riP0177, P17 BECAUSE l'U'TE "ASA VERYUCH "IS=RFP'THANANYoF His CONTINEMTAL EOuIVALENTS, THATpaIsH UNSERVATIVE THMGHTHASAMYS PFENVFRYDIFFFRENT FR7 AmY ) „L.." ,TDQi PTurD \u BECAPFE oF ITSPDTC-I",INLTH rE FCTi\PITcUrrl PLITIGALTPAflTIM, L!!!7 ITSINTELLECTUAL (7I0I15 IrPTPF i. T!!! L.) 1DoITTQp rmT.TT(.7'HASM/EP 1-,)rrt 7:7;TH!(,,7

THrlIs IT(' Pnr-Tm"T v E,Ji_ok;nr, PET' HO I; s.j.

Tm

nl-Prn

.

-

Tcsn 7!

• P,T

TTT!

r

!'.LIliLL

COFIGIPTr DP7C'7rT TV,V T:Errift'E TliTnV HPITT'APQ TIJE r„nnTe nr -y.111 rPE VEDV r in"FDYrTicr' !-: T

T^

r

.!,

! ILL

t

12r.1! r,DDI Ti^r,TTP'! FUFfl 11J,; LVL,,

Tr"!r'nET) E,\r'Crif 17

T

:L;

TLTV !

r,fln TrThrV

r711

:TT\17C n9C717

Tr-r v

P.FEFID;i: EITr

THEIIE

L

(-1\4771-1T,r

Ti7InD-Trf-

n=

,"

POLITIUL IDEAS, HE THOUGHT, SULU, SE JUDGED 7T DY THEIP SDECULATIvE ATTRACTIVHESS, PIT EY THEIP

'Qpi T TIm crvI cErvEncEs', FOPDIRKE 'EYPFPIErCY' TO 'RIGHT'.YHA?ISEXPFTIIPT IS NOTPI 0 D OssITIO ISRIGHT. 1EXP7 E SAIP,'ISTHATYPICH ISGOODFORTHECOITHITY GnPnFr)rvEpv I';DIVIDLJtL Ifl IT„„ THETESTIS PPAcTIUL DOESIT 1:!ORK? UOPOLITICALnn rimrIc

cl-pqFc,Y

CALTVOID THATTEST. SFILAPLY FOPPHRKE,PPUP,FCF YASTHEFPST ryin. r'n-rIEDATTrvl liru Tv.p. flF POLITICAL vIfl-PFS, H2.if IL_ SAF THING. Y.TEERATICP, HESilD,'ISA DISPOSPG,

IfL

TI

1; !.-

rE'H7H-T-Tr"'

'

i

1001

CH7A-_-flTnnr.T7)0/ Hr n!Hv fl!".= NCLERLTJC;H IQ .11L wr7,7-

r'lTHr TF,TIS"JOTvIEYOHICPTcHELL7v ri :1 iLr tr-r7rD

LDTT77-)c

LEONErn-Pu'rn

A'ILl

C 1 pr PTY L1.71-1 1:)7) 417 LT77V

1:

IfT,Tp r QTP:mr". TH7

TT L

YE

'

1 TL.FPTy

'Er-5JY01 CrTCP7F nF'GOOD ANDSTEAflY GPERNFENT' ANDOFCONTINUITY. THEPE ISHOMINGSIMPLE ABOUT THEEoHHD,TIoNs PF LIBERTY.THEYAPENOTTOBEFOUND EITEEP IHTHE IflDIVIDUAL PP INTHESTATE, ITTINA CFPLEX ASSOPTLENT OFHISTOPIC PIGHTS, LAuS, TTT In TT lEDCHPCPATIONS, PPLITIFAL INSTITHTIONS I TO THESE ELFFERS BETYFEN THETLDIV1Df L AHDIHESTr.TE HID!PPFSFflyr LIEEPTY OYEnHFUINGA DIPEPT oPHFRIMTIJIM FETYEFP TEri, NOTHEN LL'TPEPTY rn" DE Plin(THET AS r.flPIT) IN ITSELF , rnHHFrTETI

liTTH nDTv-nt

,

7-117

ITU'n7 i

IC HnT,

"

,

1)

f,r71 I TPTV!' FI I

•

mHTC 11iv_

PFPUP:7 rWEP THANANYOTHER Tn su7f4IsImr THOtGHT, rTFPPL , ITICAL OUOT ATIC

;

r

171flpTTfl

"r17H'*1, p55Drte,E0 M(7(L771T

iC

rTh. r

LH

lim7ED

UL77\1Efl TUT1-

I"T"FVFR, 'PC-HT u: 7-1!pr.L. cx,nm TT "T" A LY'NnTrD!TTr,ply LE7[P TrTn

ENCEOrIuFAKESITr 1J,J-I

Li_v

CflY7

:_nrcupv

pm-EP-You ArnVEAKETPF N AIPLICPTIO OFTHPT N

FIRST PPINCIPLF ITSELAND STETHING F, TnABANPON OFTHFFXTUTOFTHEITVANTAGE YOUPROPOSED BY IT, INnPnuTOPREVENT ALSOTHEINCOUVENIEYHICH UES ADISEN HAVF FRTI THEMTRUOFNT ALLTHE0000YOU flF 1-14DTHAT

IS ri)VIr YHIC'H F UoULPPF FTjlE CEMSTAnY IPrigJPYALLPOLITICAL PASTIES,

F,'"U PEF1R F CTED THELOrE-STAND PRACT IMG ICE OF PPITIFoLIT BYrIsfTnEPATE RFD)/OR SH Ics, [J2n TLEFIFS HF FLIP TOPEPPETUATE THE",AND TurE'ci 7

-HAT

rfl'!cED'irmicr' " :.L\ PrENT SYTFF :R i„.„ AN inFOLnYuncFT THE ,LnC:TPPnFOUN7 cersEPTECFQ, r1 71 T1,r7 12,HT TU.:" iFTT7 v-rIE FRITAIN, 1HL_ 11Lul r TLL: ,_ ccIr. „ 1: -117 r•) iLL.t

nH-. 1

EXITPTEIncTTU: L_1 T T,ETH DrArTTr.",r.fle :2TpTy ,i" TiLTET TO CHLIncFn 14 _,irr',T)ITTflnc, ,s.LI

-711;1_

L

nfl!'CLI-17)Y[TT\P-;'• r";77rj',

r - '

r—flflrflr-7

I

THATBRITISH COHERVATIT IDEOIOGICAL DOESNOT FANTHATITHASNO THFORETIUL BASIS. IT ISPERFECTLY POSSIBLE TO HOLDA THEORY \INCHISNOTIDEOLOGICAL AflD nICH DISTRUSTS ITSTPACT THOUG;T,ANDTHIJIS ',HAT VID,TrpLLY ML TORY 1-1-11"EPC PP THEP THORIFS "-

iH

flT

VC.

nn"r

N.- F*1

P,L,

THrn: irh_r\L

LUC

Y nc T QIN T/1T VrT" ; 1 .1 I "HICHHJ'S PEP'COrnnN 7 THELEFT) rflTF-Opy

TTLALS: PEITISH C7SEPTISr ISNOT SYST EAINCEADDrflDHATIoN FIVE7-',EEr An ITHRUnTELFF7 ,

I

,•

I_

•

r

IL;

yflp

flT

vnim cY°Trr' f.7)roDERATION,

,

H7-1.77! L

'

PY

DEFINITION, RIGHT, AND) YOUDP1:H1! 1-1TOfl7IFY IT,SIFCE THAT 7:LLD NAKEITINrEPFECT, T',UTIT Ti'DrrThr--;,!T .; Lf LA,I

r

TCL!

lc ArvITT:DIV Cfl'IcrDVITTC11 I J. ; ‘_1

IT FEJrICT7c; FIVEPSITYR ifl ik

., •=1111•11

IFEFRFECTI IFYOUDONOTHAVEA SYSTEr, _ . V YOHHAVETrFEErFIRICAL ANDYOUUVE TOWE NrunsuHcEsIHTOACCOUNT,YOUHAVEHP 'CRIF', TO [ISE OAKESHOTT'SVOR!), TOFEETEVERY COMCFIVPPLE CT!TINGENCY, YOUHAVETHERTFORE TOJUDGEISSHES ONTHEIR FERITS AflP NT FYflOCTRINE. THISrEils, Tro,OP ITsrau l'EAN, THATrEt\As APEDIFTINGUIFHED rc7(' r•.!FLL.: Fpnr' MflT FnErTED INTOENRS. TvHc YrILE PATDIOTISF An A TFLIEFIH THFNATIONAL IDENTITY HAvEAPI.YS ForrATTHEHEART OF OONFRVATIFT, THEYDIPNOTSTOPTHECONSERvATIVE FAUY,ILPESFONH TOA C AJOLoF GIPCHFSTANCES, pi-Tv T-,ErT QT,V,MFIV TMFrIWOMD PF 'nImIrr Flmnpr !, .

T I [DI V 1,L;

THE

LL

Enrt:

r7T

L.L

T

TC

"r-rHC

r'ivr

T

f rp'17)

'ELT T TP1MV Tcr! 1-,Er:HTE THEDni 'TcPI=rn'-'eF:-Wi'T H 4

,

j

CIVFTHEDTPFCTIPM Ir r

TO:V

li!L;

YrIrE

v

CHIT _

T

TP T'

mrYT

;

,

_

CDL .i

IDE

! n L TOTHESTIA.TE Tnn TO IUTEDFE: 7CE, I HOP='AiATI A7 Gofe, TO SAY

T.T

1

-

1

1 1.S

"

TO SOMEEXTENT IMPLICITIN WHAT I HA\T

ALPEADY SAID, THFREIS OP SHOULD FE, NOCOUSEPVATIVE HOSTILITY To

- STATE, THEREIS

rnCoNSEPVATIVF

Dor:TAAT-TUT THESTPTEPrD THEIFIvITUAL, CoNSERVATIVEF DP MOTSEE THSE PS FLTHALLY A7P'O-,PNISTIC PNTITIFS, BUTAS MUTUALLY ' itDF="fiT Li SHEllILILD HTITIFS, 17n VHTULLY

;

JuJIuJ

lUd Au Jd1iDJJOS V iO'fJ I AIIi LL

JO JSN5SV JIV*-AUi idi11IVJ SII(1,JV SSJNOd

IIIAO 111V91-f)i]k d dOSS1AOd Vi V f!:,JSI1V01211 Ji,*1o.):0J50AJIrlAiA 1AIIVA'd 1SNO1 SJIIS

1HI NI CHISAJOINI 5S A1HI.111,10HS AH:1

j.fUl NI d:ISAdJINI ION SI 1IVIS501AI

f

veteut.sprrtis.vscl...,7

ii

=Z....

'1150001

AI.

hV ORA010070AASIIVSION111011100011-0Vj LJ,J 0500110I AO SMIVG

AO 190lDI00011 1IV nu dAHIU

h NO (INV 00I1I110009

111 NO 55001951 '51105015

0011911000 1IVIS101 i00ANIVOA5H1331101

Ai1JA01 1000ION -MilA101dNV ildOid

'II01 AI1V1k01 1150

SiI 33510i1 1AIWcilS ION liii1L/lIS 1500V

1 T-

loi

0VII

SV Id19/5AAIAE

1iV1S

SI II

SV 1150

JJOI II 1

'5IVIS ;IV:Min-DM 011173-03 501OE SI IHROH1

•

THRFATTO IT, CONS', TRVAT IVES P;E1 I EVE

cT7-17TF 'MESIFAPLP r;DE crperf,r TlYirflQ. L T' 1"7- D'FF T

LiL_!

T

ra!!--

-i-!; r,1;TTL=Dr

EY

•

.

;

!_L_

n

•

!!! L_ I •

r T 12; r" I L

TO FENT? $10,C00 TO VICTIVS OF DROUGHT, SAYINC4: 'FEDERAL AID IN SUCH'CASFS „„ YEAKESTHE STHRDIHFSS OF ()HP !WFIUNL cHff?AcTEP' THATYAS LIDEPALDOGFA AT ITS VORST,

CONSEPVATIVFS PN ;HPCPNTRAPY PELIFvPYITH ETKE TUT (;OvEP7PT IF 'ACIMTRIWNCE CF fL YISTOFTO -PCVIPEFOPHUflAN

OHLALIFFPA1

FEnnafs, NT cusFRVATIVEs, [rCrITA,10/ r)T

[...!

LJ

$

LI

ODPOSED TO THF "FLFARESTATE, ;7-n

CHI \ft CONSERVATIVF INSTITHTIOfl - YEICHISHY CU:SEPVATIVFS rflrET

;;_1::;:

Y 7 IPSOrLCH TnFDIrEITT7 non7c L,;u1„,, P7 T-1) ri777 E i7 r 7 I

T)Fri=r--\Dr

L

‘,/

1-"Tc1-7Hrr A7! ITS

PITOPY,

ETD cci,,c'EnvT,T IVESTrE

c'T[T'-I El re

Ti7

Tv

nry.-7:-

r:r\Dv SOCILLH—IT,

Dfl:,.!

15 T'7.TIT-1"r[j, Fi*FILIES SHILLrQ FAD

NIDWIPEDTOLOCT PFT=P THFTSEPTS, YET,ITISOFYINS THATTHEPF ARENAM FAKILIES AHD, INDIVIDUALS 1*-0 FINDITDIFFICULT CRILPOSSIFLF TOLouAFTER THFSFLVFS, I REPRESENT A PFLATIVELY PPOSPFROUS COESTITUEECYJ FITEvENIN CHESHAL ANDA.;.IPSHAfl THFRE APE''"'" PEOPLE "H° HPOETEDLY HED HELP HIT THESTATE OR p.m LOHL 5wr.PN7F-7,

v"'TTEr°R°RnRTTnH HELPSH5ULD FE, Cflrird A7 !JOY FUrTrfl'Jfv OHHLD CDCf'T C." c,,:flyfrrc IC !..ATTEDnE LnD -Th'eFfIr I\LA

'7

TUFDF

'

T

PFFICE FEr-USE YrSIrrLY COUin IF

cf,7

Hr.-7

7r

u:!T

- nT Irr,cT rti''7QC'171-1 7,77,

, Tr,--nr, R:U i1--'-*

Tr,

(fl

fl" LH

Yr tril:nr

PUTGRAPUAL Cff!GE IS ALVAYS PRFFERqlF TO VIOLENT CHANGE, FORFLECTnRAL REIST!FUNE', Pups. .ATDPEOPLENEFDTOBE CnNVINCER THATTHEY,ILL PE

BETTER OFF,NoT MRSEOFF,AS A RESULT OFPERInDS or CnS FPV,UIvE GOVERNLPT. VE HAVETOURRY TV PUNTRYYITHUS, IT1-"OHLD BEFOLISH TO FORGET Trls, To Tr7E A71PGLITIM TEAT'!-E UN IGpnu THF0(1IA1 CONSECUEN CESOr YW\T

Hr 0L T-11-•

CF

FIH:=r

TL)F 1,;(7,nn

T

(r,

.J l

j

Th77 ,L

LLL

nL

OELAHYE

:

7Erlf:_!: 070Hnfc Frrnp in r=nrry nifrcTricsrflnl!Tr CIPPTI-Jr , .," 7ITE IT FIFFICLLT t

L'YIT!!riTi!TTl-!' TLE

f"-vT 7:1.;vErrc.'

oPc,r:QTflTLJA,T

7TL

r!-7-----,Tr-,flTr TT

pArrl

A.I_ j7E

(-)7

flT

TIC['

Cupw1-1 _ rT ,ruEm I-PPE f'pmEM VLV

HUSTOTLAKETHESATEFISTAKE ASflARY, AHDCIVE ECOKFIC CONSPERATIONS FPIMACY OVEPFOLITIPAL Pm FQ

THErl AREOFCOHPFE A FE.' BASIC RiAP, FIRST, TURF IS A [urn CHCHANGE THE - Tn Fr! r,1

rpriIc CANLCCEPT AN71 unDFRSTPmP, ESPECIPILY IFITIFFOPCED THPOHET AT-Mr)FAST' PACE,

FECOHT-1, IT YOHLD DEDIFFICHLTTP P,ETAP8 HIHIL7 PFPHBI ICSrPATLY pmPsupenTPIHRT(' THEPAPPHI PFRInfl OFADJUSTLENT THRPHH P "uT CH OnD EPPH7Y7ST PASSIF TrEPE :A.S A ,cHAP nrrLINE 11

. „,

TH

r

T rTr!TT; 0 7-

n77'7, T f!

I

r

n7,n

EHET SPELL NT TIrE'D GILTHE1*--mnprsr CUPpnnpu7TFCC

rHTn !

nE7

SPFrE rTHE

I_ Jr\67_ Tir:!=.1.1 TCE7! Tfl YI.Yr

;

HE

.

f!r IT Tr, cs.r.n

L_

•7-:-)

HCFPY

HHPITALS KIDEEl LER, C REFR THEHEETYJ HE1 ALL ru FEABLETOAFFORD TPLT LNTIL rE PAVE FADETHESORTOFSHIFT INTHEECOOTY ABOHT 1 !!HICH BACON ANDELTIS rOTFSOCONVINCINGLY A FP-YEARS AGO, FOURTH, PSUNFULOYFENT RiSFS R:-PIDLY THIS YEAR, 1:!E HILLHAVE Tn1-Frns,TPur HflT OPLY CONCERN FORTHFSOCIAL FPIICATIMS PUTALSO ILAGINATIM POUTT E PEHRFS OFTHELABOUR PARKET AD OFPAYPARGAINING UHICHnqn HELP 7 CPEATF JOFSPATHEP THAfl iiESTROY THEN.

rim,7,r-r,o/rmi\f7c t: :77Q, LflOK

F.t

1-

L.%

Trr'.pTrnmr-to;r.r TyP :

DISA'r`Yn Ai-fl r H rOHTFO-, rE

Cry:TILT;THq E pn

Tnry! n7

PET7'IC

1,r-1v flYTUTT LJ

TT7nr,1T-r-v

RFPLITY, ErwTErE7-

IUI

LLETT F2,1t7.-“:TTT

i

Lflr77-nRTI7\T!V !

Hfl

rE

r‘fri 1,

!In; ..t :

nnTTr“!!

VERYATITACTIVF IN 1071, LTT FIFTYHAPaYLOCTED THEY STILL KN THEELECTIM ASLEOVERYSAI7 IN1945, PEOPLE YoTE AECUToPHDTHIL' 's DEFEAT E TS NOTAGAPST OPPOSITIoNS, 'I"T GflVEFr1L SOYHILE I AGREE THATIT'ALLTAKETILEFORrsTO REVIVE THEECOMOLY ANDTHATYFAPFENPARKED ON THEPESTPART P PROGRAFFF THAT ODIC FLLTAKE TYP°11C1-4 T PLSONoTE OF T"O F"LIA"F''Ts inCADRY THAT LEPTEN THEFIRST PARLIAFENTTH=SFC07 THFELECTORATE 'ALLPAVEITSCHANCE OFA SAY. 12/'

Anr),

A=TEP THAT ,L.TEJ7! TOFYORIGIU,L THEM

D"FH-12rCIC

IHQTT T THEt.),,i:11

IS

I

n

Ty 1J1

IM T

TUE

pc,v1=p-T-v ET,n7 CTI,TF L_ TT°i ;

T ;"rET '

EVTE T

T

ynii!nTtPv DnriTrc pp LPV 1 L.,

T"!

THE-

D1'

7

T

n

I,

7v *W TV

r-LEL f:t

1 .7I

r.

.

-71-

Tr ihurnr-r,"'r' Crrt:^7TV

IC'

rn

iT

C

OEP IT ENLDP

THP""

V T L,1

n-

Tc-c:Lnr'Hr: LL

r nrcH!T

OFLOYER TAXATION AU A PORESHCCEcc,FHL FC0"n"v srpVICP ARFFIrr7ED ANDTHEEXTFNT TOPHICH SOCIAL PYTAXATION J)CHAPGFF, DONOTSHEN TOrFToFE rATTERS OFHNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLE. CERTAINLY LIFEISNOTr PLACF, Afl7 THE COHTRY PHSTNOTFETH7FPrToOUE PHTOTHER. COUNTRIES PAVECOPFINED PARKET ANT' YFLFARF PRINCIPLFS mOTEFUoCESSFUL1Y TVflYF HAVE, THEPIHToONSFRVATIVF ATTITHRF TOSTATF 1 INTHEUT:7Y ISTOrYrIrDSIrILAP IJEPTEPUCE

flji A11VOIdIcAl dN.JAldVIE]AdAI ATIVDILIdC]H! NlO2 ]A 01 SA-TAS IJI

OffAi

Th11L'i

GNV(-AIM 1-11AO SIINVHIII iUd 1VOIII1Ud 11V rIIVIS \

dihur

DIAOHODA TIV AI

FZAHI

NI Eld111;1

HI O SLINVHHI

I SI

'AOd]lidA AONOIIILINGD

AdVSS-AOAN V SI kAIOOD]]AdA eoMIA

V

TNICITIONI -

IFilAdJAANI TEV1V: SA_TAS ACIOi(1009V FNV _INONOAIII6dIlIMA LIDN,FIVINilNV lAi

ATIVHSil

SI HOLVPJAIXA

dinUA I

AJ

A1.) 01 Si;ITI) r

u;:t1

! i°,A

_1 -)

I

/3AHLilytu • ;

A 7 T. 4 rs"7

T

T

(1;

7n

1../LL

°

-1171

T-11 iftJ

77-444,

4

_.iI

•

7!..27p7:7flnl._ Enif--A —Prr r,n iL_H Unt_.I Ffl""V rr

rj7. 7-7" 7WP"p

;,,r;

r

T

r

,

7,

I

Lt... I

r,1

TrE T7.7

n

Hnrli

t

E7 rrfl!,-n-v

r r

rfln't11'y iIiiPE

TIv..R 1"-PrHn -

71Th

E

ETH

n

r1--i'

r-

r "!'") ,

+ THE IL

TN /

1,1

r i

nrrc

HAYEK,

\JON rIsEs'sCPITIOUE OF INTERVEflTIONISI" ISLIKE11P,X, IN ITSo GrATISfl, ITSHISTnRICIS7, ANDITSAKPLITUEOF INACCHRATE DPOPHECY,ACCPRPINO Tn HIMANYCOVFPNrENT INEPFERENCE INTHEEUMPflY ISEnUKDTO FAT,TO SOCIAJISfl OP CHAOS, THAT SE-7STO ME Tn Tr'riFFOSIPP !Inmcr=r1QE:

INHIS'POADTO SERFDON:', HAYEK--)UT A SINMP pnrm IL

TOPPGI,." !In-ippcITF 10_,U H

Ey-Tor"rYny.

YPfliF, 'T''T ISOFTEn 'ALL r,OT TOLERATE CAPTTI'l IFCLPIT12.LIS:' EU I

T7

rrv 7 "DETTTP/E L;iiivL nr--;-DIATL7

Tic

7nr7r,rv

I

.",

CoTi.71,

FT;im:-nrLTD7v F,,..1-L-11,11LH-sr

I

LI

7-rnr.r.r-‘,! Enn:

7-)Tcnncrl

LtI.

T Tc

'TTir'AT Y "T71_11,T pc -cc TriEl

-

TT

cNCTP c

'

Tc:7

i

CERTAINLY TPUE, D,UT YHATIFTHEFIP.ST PROPOSITION ISALP TPUE? IFTHEPHIPLE LILLNOTACCEPT uNiprisr ASau, IT1:!ILL DPLITTLE GOODTOTELLI Efl POTHIrG ELSE ISCOMPATIBLE 'ITHDEMOCRACY,CONFRONTED YITH SUCH A CHOICE, THEYMAYYELLOPTFORTHE riON-DITOCRATIC ALTEUATIVE, INHISEJ).K, 'THF flIDDLF 1W',HAROLD UonILUr. P/PnEssr-T rIsRFLIEF THAT'IFCAPITIIISr HADTHEPCOHDUCTED ALLALONG ASIFTHETHFORY nFPRIVATE ENTEPPRI0JYERF MTH OFPPIHIPLY, ANDALLINTERvFNTION TYTHFSTATE PAnPEEPPFSISTEn, 'YESHOUIP VVE HADFIVIL 1!AR LONG AGO'. TflurEpImo T F SYHIP TflFODIFYlitL'flrIflY.T' LJA, T"Y P"TY , HAYEK'SSECOND PROPOSITION IS

!

c:r.,

I

"Ti'17

Tfl

i

.

T ,L",,CflEFT17.1 F ToT H F ELECTflnr:TE, L.

TWT

HHILE FT?ri--

—

fl7TLTrTTflmc

fT,T Q:7,711 I

:

t- A •Ft.LIfl

r

r -Li

FL—. rrrH

L

r

LL Tcr."

r: 7' 7:

1_L'

7-;, fl

uHicu

VET !Li

7

7'

IS TH.7--V

;

"

!flT

TW:

1

r

I I V

(')nr,Ti

7:7

171

T7,7'.

,

rc Tr-

TT

1

TTL, TL'E11

r.

P

Y

\

OLITI CIL i

PFFIEFETEFPRISE 5"55 THEr'ART,,1:111 THEYARE7ADY YILLIre TO REFEDY THEN".THEYDO NOTBELIEVE THATTHERROFIT NOTIVE SILLSOLVE ALLECONOSIC PROBI EFS, THEREIS'In TORYPUIvALEAT OFI IIPOUR PARTY'S CLAUSE b.. ITSEENS TOSEFAIRLY CLEAR THAT-PTOFTHE REASONS IJI,Y ';IE HAVEFALIEN ECONONICALIY SOFAR FEHIHD LOSToFOUROTPETITOPS ISTHATSE HAVE SUCHA LARGE RUFLIC SECToR AND1::E HAVEP IrOOD DEA! URE GOVERH"E"TAL T"TERrERCE I"THErflO"Y LiLi °" THAN LOSTOF THE. I L'ELIEvE "T'THLT r0FETTER IFPE HADrOPEOFA SARY,FT FCONTY.

n7 THESEFOITS THLT "FI ST ,,

IT IS

•/1--i TIJ TIT7t7---Yr-PT PETITE ' CO"Sr: TT\47(7' r -rpr

_ nr, HPT

['UT"

Cfn!.L"

-

fl

r-rm

n-

TLCP1.17.17

1 ILL

'

rr

SFENED TO REALISE -

,

I

h 1 t

1 ,TRIES NITHECCHONJES rUCH THEFT Is. A GOODPEALoFGOVEP NNENT P.L " INTERFEPENCE ANDTHATE\ !EN IFOURECONONY I:!AS KRKINGrucHrORE EFFICIENTLY THANITISTHERE YOULD STILL FE PETTY CFSCORE FORGOVERNFENTAL ACTIVITY,

A TORY, THEN, DOESNOTDELIEVE THAT.`11 SINGLE ECONONIO DOCTRINE ORPOLICY IFOARAPLE OFYHOLLY EXPLAINING, GUIDING, OPPPEDICTPG ECOOFICACTIVITY, INTHESAMEVAYTHATHE BELIEVES THATALLPOLITICAL DOCTRINES UR POLICES RETOA GREATER OR LESSER DEGREE DEFECTIVE.

THEE 17,11.!!

TC !"fl

PDTI-M7yY ,

crTri T!,T.!!C!'7E) Tfl J

TH,7 OTTA'I 1 HEPEDTflE 1 7:

Ijr)

CH_

C-f-rw HL c i-JP, 'TS

ITT

IS

T

rIrTrFn uLl„; 1.., TH.7

TPOSE

IrTncrn

0;,_;

A !-

n7nr H7HT FL:

DV./n1TEUT"!-7 j

F-r`, I V FDD:::.A.: ELCEI TT,;';_ :7flT OF

T

trril

['AT)

'ETAT C

7.-HE ILL

TI,17 ;

CuC 1-Tr,

(:—.7"'"n7 F.7

7 7 rti,yj-n

HE

T TUT',

"

THEINTERVENTIONIST STATEANDTHFYELFADE -1-ATE APEHOTGOIHGTO GO A'!./.Y, THATISSTETHPG, AS I HvE INDICATED, ,TICHI YFIC•F, THOSEI,' BELIEVE OTHERYISE mE, ID ryVIEY,FOLLFNINTO THETPAPOF IPEcdoGY OLDDO7A - YHICHIS , OP cUrollp PF PPD/=,P,71E C, TO Cr-HQFPWTTVCO TnL I "C L' :

o

;:rvEPTPFLFY ESS, PEUNrGGoV7RNITHT INTEDVENTIoN ANDBY B7DHCIHG THEPg.:EOF RS TH7BUPEAHCRACVE Y, r1H vH SHALL NCIAL)

TAILDING UP

TH7

E1 nrn

ELF

WA

THF FCOHOPY "7 QMI,

UTFTITY OF

r-nriTY'717-1-

7:

SIPCEIT

1

1 'd]H1]9011V AAOHOTA 3H1

.33A1uA3N ]19jISV S1VSDAOr SIHGOAJVJ iJI dAdlVdAJAHJ AO INOJVANV 01 add]Al-id SAn1V 3 EVIL11Iddihri0A Di AO AlDNIA0ddcV ]10 ]30 AK3SI1VS 'AiINLIAOD AO ISWASV 9

(1S]dd1111ljTS-AH1 iV 1L

lvnGIAILmI

A:11 L-0=1 'AOCIATA 1I0JH9rilid1 ]ONVADJAd DIONODj.d]1111 V di IMOD 01 'd]HiVd SI ';ISVI JUcJ hVIS 111-AA01Ad 01 1E]l1V NV A2 GJAUASAdd

Jd 1JHGNOM AIIKHEIViVR1 (1V]did 01

`.`,"T•

rsI

-;1's JJ_11,3

(in2

;,) _, LIG'jHL!!!)

JU

n -4

3: .;

7, 7

7'

JJ

33013 n

i

u

21

!,.'YT!!!

,

J

11,11-1,7 L.-31

7 '4H C1 3.,1 1

1":1V-

L"T

3LIJC1':;11.,!1

.._,!1

iU

•

T I 7V ;

7

, ,

17-1!"'"-.7r7;',ITTPI:C

4

TE

TC;T,7'!DV'C-

f"r-:

,

T

c'T11f., --,,

T —I 7 /

PITT

Tc

nm-

c

or-T-;,m7 riTHYHICH I BPTAN, TOA FUNDAVENTAL CONSIR"'TIVE TENET: THAT POLITICAL THEORY SHOULD NEVER GPTINTHE1!!AY nFsErsITIF POLITICAL ACTION. ;

•

••.ssar•opomeam.......

AmDSOSALISBURY'S ITRDS FAKEA SMITAPLY PPACTICAL ETPF:TOA FCTURE ONCONSERVATISF.